Reviews for Feedbro - RSS Feed Reader
Feedbro - RSS Feed Reader by Nodetics
763 reviews
- Rated 4 out of 5by Martin Strobl, 7 years agoAs a long time useer of the Sage++ (Higmmer's Edition) reader I have been looking for adequate replacement for the Firefox Quantum. The FeedBro is closest alternative, however, I really miss the "update all feeds now" button.
Developer response
posted 7 years agoThank you for your review.
Note that Feedbro scans for new articles automatically in the background so "Update all feeds" button shouldn't be really necessary. Also when you open Feedbro first time in the browser session, it will trigger a scan.
However, we have just added the button to the toolbar (available in Feedbro 3.32.4) since some users want to have very long (or none at all) automatic scanning interval and want to manually check for changes. Note also that this approach makes you easily lose updates since if you only check for new articles every 6 hours and feed publishes 20 articles per hour and only keeps the latest 20 in the XML, you lose many articles since they are no longer available in the XML.
Note also that it's quite resource intensive to check all feeds at once (especially if you have hundreds of feeds). But since many people have asked for this - here it is. :) - Rated 5 out of 5by Yearling, 7 years agoI'm very satisfied, this addon is still better and better. The developer improves this add-on very quickly, so I hope it will soon replaces the previously used NewsFOX.
Now I have only one small suggestion - it is not possible (yet :-)) to synchronize the list of feeds with multiple computers or import it directly from the browser bookmark (not via HTML or OPML).Developer response
posted 7 years ago1. Feedbro 3.34.0 now has "view mode 6" that uses an iframe to embed the original article.
2. There's now a button in Options that lets you import Firefox bookmarks. However, due to WebExtension bookmarks API limitations, it's currently not possible to read them automatically or to keep the feed subscriptions as Firefox bookmarks - Feedbro has to maintain the feed list internally. - Rated 5 out of 5by Firefox user 13415797, 7 years ago
- Rated 4 out of 5by Firefox user 13145241, 7 years agoI also used Bamboo before and liked it more, since it was simpler and did what i wanted. What bothers me the most is how Feedbro reacts to Feeds with the same Timestamp. It should just list all.
The other thing is, not matter what I set for "Maximum Entries to save" in a specific Feed, it just uses the default Settings of 100. Maybe thats have something to do with the Timestamp but its just displays 100.
A single Button to Update every Feed would be very usefull. And an option to disable the source under every Feed.
Good addon though, which could need some Improvements.
-edit-
Ok, than thats the Problem.^^ A single HTTP load request should load more than 100 feeds :-)
-edit2-
Iam going to raise my review to 4 Stars. The refresh all button is now there and the warning will be disabled in a future Update. Nice!
But: Please change it so the HTTP load request will load more than 100 feeds. Iam missing something because the addon only loads 100 entries. Thats the reason iam still stuck with Firefox 56 and Bamboo. 5 Stars after that have been fixed.Developer response
posted 7 years ago"What bothers me the most is how Feedbro reacts to Feeds with the same Timestamp. It should just list all."
What do you mean? Feedbro does not hide or drop any articles based on timestamps.
"The other thing is, not matter what I set for "Maximum Entries to save" in a specific Feed, it just uses the default Settings of 100."
This is not really true. The default setting does affect how many articles Feedbro fetches from the feed source (XML) with a single HTTP load request (maximum being 100 at once) but if you set a feed specific max entries to save e.g. to 500, that's the maximum amount of articles that feed can contain - it will just take some time to accumulate that number of articles. Which feed URLs publish more than 100 articles at once?
Edit: Feedbro 3.35.2 can now load N articles with one HTTP GET request. N is the maximum number of items to save for the feed so if the feed has a feed specific max value, it can be even 2000. - Rated 3 out of 5by Firefox user 13469213, 7 years agoTrying Feedbro while Brief updates to work on FF57
There's a lot of small issues here and there: lack of support for Live bookmarks (which Firefox has been using for some years now), UI unpredictability and general weirdness (Not only can't I set an exact number of minutes for scan interval, you chose to represent a year as 525600 minutes!), can't drag'n'drop links for fast feed creation, can't select multiple feeds... Mostly minor UI stuff that builds up and makes the add-on annoying to deal with, but It seems likely that they'll get fixed over time.
What really stands out is the rules system. I've got a feed that's always giving me trouble, both here and back on Brief, where marking the "don't mark updated articles as unread" checkbox solved it's hijinks, but since Feedbro lacks that I tried to solve it with rules. The hijinks this time is that every time the scan interval completes, a single, old article reappears as brand new, and my gut feeling was to use the rules to compare if the time at which it was detected was more recent than the earliest article. Sadly, you can't compare articles, nor check any kind of time atribute. So as a emporary measure I've placed a rule to mark all updates from said feed as read, and not notify me of said updates. Bummer.
Then there's another feed that usually posts multiple articles at once, to be read in a particular order. Since notifications are per article, when the update hits I get spammed with notifications, and was about to set a rule to check wetherarticles have been posted within seconds of each other, only to remember I can't check that. Bummer again.
Those are just two specific cases, what Im really trying to get at is that the rules system has the potential to become an incredibly powerful tool.
TL;DR: Feedbro really shows potential to become great, but right now it's just fine and usable. Won't be using it yet, but will definitely come back to check again in a few months to see what's changed.Developer response
posted 7 years agoThank you for your review and observations.
We'll fix the display of the hard to read intervals. It's true that it's difficult to understand what 525600 minutes stands for. :)
We have noticed that a lot of people who used a different reader before have their subscriptions as Live Bookmarks. Unfortunately the Firefox WebExtension implementation does not let you read Live Bookmarks via the API which makes it impossible for the add-on to use or to import them. We are hopeful to see a change in the API but this will most likely take some time. See Bugzilla bug: https://bugzilla.mozilla.org/show_bug.cgi?id=1418257
Unfortunately there are some feeds that don't follow the rules or behave in somehow peculiar manner. Usually the best option is to notify the feed provider that they should fix the feed rather than trying to fix N different readers to deal with their problems. If e.g. feed posts several articles with the same date stamp and you still want to see notifications, how should the reader behave? Show just the first? Show none? Show all but with larger intervals in between? - Rated 4 out of 5by Firefox user 13465077, 7 years agoI used Newsfox before the FF57 update so now I'm using this, and I really like it. Even more than Newsfox.
The only features that I miss are the option to open all the unread entries of a feed in new tab and, more important, the update of old entries when they are updated on the feed.
Overall great addon. - Rated 4 out of 5by Firefox user 13229219, 7 years agoBest RSS-Reader I tried so far but unfortunately it can't sync over different devices.
I know that Feedbro can't Sync to Mozilla. But maybe it is possible to sync to my Homeserver or Dropbox or whatever!?!?
If there is any possibility to sync already read articles over different devices I will update to 5 stars! :) - Rated 5 out of 5by Firefox user 12798619, 7 years agogreat addon ! I used Sage until FF 57 was released and it stopped working but since I started with FeedBro (just few days now) and it is much. much more advanced. fast, easy, simple.
One small request if it will be possible to add for a future release: add a link to the source web page. for example: i use FeedBro mainly for youtube. as the youtube feed is limited to the last 15 entries per channel, you want to be able to open the channel's page and browse for the missing upload you didn;t have in the feed.
Maybe to add the link above the view of the feeds or something...
Other than that: great piece of software !
Omer.Developer response
posted 7 years agoEach article should have a link to the feed source web page on the "From line" under the article title. - Rated 5 out of 5by cristianhcd, 7 years agoFunciona muy bien y la interfaz es bastante parecida a la que usaba en opera
- Rated 4 out of 5by gggeek, 7 years agoInstalled the plugin 15 minutes ago.
So far I have: added a couple of feeds, played around with the options to customize the GUI.
Everything seems to be working as it should, which is more than I can say of most of the pre-FF-57 feed readers.
The choice in available view modes is great!
My 1st feature request would be: allow to import rss feed definitions from a set of bookmarks (ie. a bookmark folder and its subfolers).
That's because it is the format that is used by Sage (my previous reader) to store the list of feeds.
I know that import from OPML is possible, and it could do, if not for the export-bookmarks-to-opml FF extension not being 57-compatible!Developer response
posted 7 years agoThank you for your review.
Feedbro 3.32.0 now has a button in Options that you can use to import selected Firefox bookmarks as HTML (first export them in Firefox of course). PS. It seems that Chrome uses the same format for bookmarks HTML export so it's possible to import Chrome bookmarks with the same button as well. - Rated 4 out of 5by Underpass, 7 years agoI'm trying to replace NewsFox and this addon seems to be good enough.
Is it possible to hide the upper section (All items, Starred items, etc.) altogether thus making more room to the feed?
Is it possible to have the "normal" layout with the article list in the upper half and the preview in the lower hald of the page?
Thanks. - Rated 5 out of 5by trap000d, 7 years agoAll good, just a few issues, however a bit annoying:
1. No option for font size in tree view (hardcoded 11pt, why?)
2. A 3-panel layout (like as in NewsFox) is highly appreciated. Yes, you have to change several css rules from flex to block and place one of drawers horizontally. Sorry if it breaks your conception of modern design.
3. Definitely need an option for hotkeys customization.
4. Not an ideal UX, e.g. there is no way to switch from full article to headers list or tree view without mouse. - Rated 4 out of 5by Kat, 7 years agoHello.
I like your extension. It replaces my old one and is visually very appealing. But I have a major problem, so I can't give you 5 Starts yet.
I can't seem to select particular feed entries and mark them as read OR unread. Somehow my feeds got marked as read (I think I figured out why) but I've not read half of them yet. So I wanted to select a batch of feed entries and mark then unread but it's impossible. I can not click on the feeds without extending them (a manual "extend", "collapse" function for each entry would be great for the views where there feeds are not extended by default) and can't select multiple entries either. Apparently I couldn't find even a mass "mar unread" option. :'D
I'd be very grateful if you fix this!
You might want to change keys, too, or allow their adjustment. Because when I type "m" to mark as read/unread for a single thread, firefox starts the in-site search function. Since this has been bugging me anyways I've removed that function in the configurations but I doubt that most users will do that
===========
EDIT as Reply to creator's reply: Yes I adjusted how the articles are markd as read. Still it'll be important to allow the selection of several articles to mark or unmark them.
Regarding the search bar: No it was set like that by default in the Firefox Quantum build. But then again it was synchronised with my old Profile so who knows X'D. Anyways "accessibility.typeaheadfind" was set on "true" instead of "false" in "about:config" ig´f anyone ever has the same problem. It's gone now so if it's just a bug on my side and no problem for others then that's great!Developer response
posted 7 years agoThank you for your review!
Please open Options page. There you can select how articles are marked as read. Default is when the title of the article is shown (quite "eager" mode), another option is when the bottom of the article is shown (requires that you expand articles and scroll to the end) or manually by unchecking "keep unread" checkbox or by pressing 'm'.
Edit: Feedbro 3.35.0+ fixes the keyboard shortcut issue you mentioned. - Rated 4 out of 5by Firefox user 13435581, 7 years agoHi! Great addon !
My wish : feedbro count the global number of article per tag. It will be great to count the number of unread article per tag or just put a flag on a tag with new article !Developer response
posted 7 years agoIn "Tags" menu you can see how many articles in total have a specific tag. But if I understand you correctly, you'd like to also see the number of unread articles that have a specific tag? If so, that's perfectly doable and we can add it to the Product Backlog. - Rated 4 out of 5by Firefox user 13427027, 7 years agoJust migrated from LiveClick which has been discontinued. It does everything I need except one thing. Could you please highlight feed folders that have unread items in them. Otherwise I have to mouse over every folder to look for unread items.
Developer response
posted 7 years agoEach folder should show the number of unread articles on the right side of the folder name. - Rated 5 out of 5by alecox, 7 years agoHi! Great addon :)
could you add to the menu the option to update all feeds manually instead of one by one? It would be convenient directly from the icon on the bar
Thanks - Rated 5 out of 5by Jagan, 7 years ago
- Rated 5 out of 5by Relven, 7 years ago
- Rated 4 out of 5by Ruhollah Majdoddin, 7 years agoUnfortunately the add-on does not take advantage of Firefox Synchronisation, one should setup his feeds manually for each device.
- Rated 5 out of 5by Anatoli, 7 years agoHi! Nice add-on, thank you!
I've just experiencing one problem with my FF56@Ubuntu: when I right-click on the feeds in the tree view on the left, I get a common menu as on any page, but the help says I would get a menu to rename the feed and perform other actions. Could this be due to NoScript and uBlock origin? Of is this something with FF56?
It would be a 6-stars add-on if you could allow to place feeds on the bookmarks menu the same way the LiveClick add-on does it. I guess it won't take that much effort having the back-end already implemented. I suppose it could be placed there with drag&drop from the tree-view and with a checkbox from the feed options. You could get all their users with this feature as LiveClick won't be rewritten for WE (I'm one of them).
A small suggestion: could you please place the favicon of the feed below each article title (i.e. in "from ") and (optionally, with a check in settings) make the the same as the name one choses for the feed? E.g. for https://thehackernews.com feed I see now: "from The Hacker News by noreply@blogger.com (Mohit Kumar)". It could be replaced by: " ".Developer response
posted 7 years agoThank you for your review and comments!
The right-click problem is a bit tricky to pin down. A few other users have reported it as well but we haven't been able to reproduce it on our Linux installations. Hard to say what is causing it. 3.30.0 has one extra preventDefault() call. Hopefully it fixes that issue for you. Please also ensure that in about:config you have key 'dom.event.contextmenu.enabled' set to true. If it's false, it disables right-click context menus.
Regarding the favicon suggestion there's now a new Option 'Use favicons in article "from line"' that enables the icons in view mode 2 and when expanding articles in other modes. Off by default because it can make the list look a bit "busy". - Rated 4 out of 5by Firefox user 13334934, 7 years ago
- Rated 5 out of 5by DanaMW, 7 years agoI have been using Sage for years and I thought I was all set with it until I was forced to look elsewhere because of FF 57. You my new friend out did yourself. FANTASTIC reader. Every inch of it is polished and trim. It was like going from a bike to a Lexus. What a great reader. I am so glad I found it and hope you work on some other projects for this new Firefox. Would be a shame not to. Thank you for this work.
- Rated 4 out of 5by Firefox user 13305990, 7 years agoI have for many years been using the Newsfox add on and consider it to be one of the the best however it appears that it may not be amended to work in FF57 and above. I have been evaluating Feedbro as an alternative and I am impressed with it.
However I would like to make a suggestion - as others here have noted - to have an additional view mode similar to the 3 pane format of Newsfox as I find this to be the most efficient way to select and read articles.
Thanks.