Unreliable, and beind used maliciously to target the very people it was intended to safeguard. Sort of like categorizing individuals in an either/or binary is not an ideal method of moralization.

I used to love this extension, but now I gotta say, it's no longer working as intended. One of the instructions to "Mark as anti-trans{...}opposition to gender-affirming care and enby-phobia." is being ignored or dismissed - I have seen people marked red who are actively defending nonbinary, intersex & even other binary trans people, and some of the most vitriolic hatred towards other trans people (as in actual calls for violence, as in "I hope these people get put down like dogs") from accounts marked green.

It feels like this service is increasingly being used to facilitate & legitimize intracommunity oppression and drama (eg, someone who said all transphobia is bad is marked as red & that is frequently an argument used against her), and frankly, life's too short for that. If this isn't resolved, I'm unfortunately gonna have to part ways with this extension – I can use my own understanding of how transphobia works & is disseminated.

Used to be a very useful addon, but lately (maybe due to a change of who's in charge?) has been flagging accounts for things that really shouldn't be flagged, such as people who talk about intersex and transmasc issues.
This shouldn't be used for infighting.

More and more often I'm finding people maliciously and incorrectly flagged red to silence them because people don't like them. Talk about trans men having issues? Flagged red because apparently that's transphobic now. Call for unity in trans communities instead of infighting? Apparently that's transphobic now. Talk about transphobia in trans spaces or other bigotry in trans spaces and trying to find ways to make our communities safer for each other? Apparently that's also transphobia now. Great idea in theory but it's being so much more widely misused as to be useless now. I would stay away for now. Uninstalling it myself because it's genuine just easier to manually check users I'm unsure about at this point.

Good in concept. However, I've been recently seeing a concerning amount of (pro-trans) intersex advocates marked a anti-trans. Transmasc and nonbinary advocates have been targeted too, as well as trans women who support them.

Furthermore, the developer(s) have unfortunately shown an intersexist and anti-nonbinary attitude in responses to some reviews, as well as their official guidelines (the assumption that "AFAB transfemme" is necessarily an anti-trans false flag when it is a label most often used by intersex people for one, as well as the assertion that "theyfab", an anti-nonbinary slur popularized on 4chan, isn't transphobic).

This is making me think the moderator(s) are using this extension as a weapon for intra-community discourse, which is antithetical to the goal of creating a safe community for all trans people.

This is the only time I have ever bothered to review an extension, really good for people like me who like infighting and human suffering

Used to be very useful, but now is being weaponized against transmasc and intersex people for talking about their experiences and oppression

this add-on used to be fantastic, but apparently the author of the plugin not only approves of but also has started advocating marking intersex, non-binary, and trans men / trans masculine people as transphobic (making their name red). this is absolutely unacceptable and i will no longer be using this extension, despite it having been a great help prior.

while i really like the concept of this, the metrics by which users are being categorized bothers me. why are people who are ADVOCATING for nonbinary/intersex/transmasc people getting marked red (transphobic)?? i kind of wanna make a better version of this actually but idk if i will... maybe over christmas break. ah well...

If people who are not transphobic, but advocating for intersex, non-binary, transmasc people are marked as red, this is no longer a tool that is useful for my safety online, but just another intersexist tool

This add-on is being used as a tool to suppress intra-community discussions. In particular those who voice support for the experiences of trans masculine, non-binary, and intersex individuals are at risk of being marked as transphobic.

This used to be an extremely helpful add-on for helping to identify queerphobes online. Unfortunately, the creator behind this add-on is unwelcoming of intersex people within our community. Intersex people, and Intersex-Welcoming people will be marked red by this extension. The creator has also spoken ill of Intersex people in replies to reviews. Community is about togetherness, and Queerness is about acceptance. Not being welcoming of Intersex people in our community is destroying the bond of togetherness and acceptance.

this USED to be extremely helpful in marking who/what is and isn't trans-friendly but recently has been falsely marking people who are intersex, transmasc, or trans men as "transphobic" for discussing their experiences with transphobia. absolutely insane and no sign of this being fixed either as the creator apparently wants it to be this way. absolutely malicious and useless extension masked as being helpful to the trans community.

This extension used to be really helpful. It used to be that you would be able to know if a newly discovered youtube channel has been transphobic in the past, or a creator you've only heard of in passing be marked as trans friendly or safe. It used to be a huge benefit and helped me navigate the internet for -years-.

I started questioning it a little while ago and I noticed trans men getting marked. I started noticing posts on antiblackness in the trans community where op was marked in red. There was recently a massive upswing in intersex users being targeted as well, for pointing out outrageous intersexism in the queer community as a whole. They added -in the guidelines- for submitting users that using the transphobic slur theyfab is not enough to be marked red. Notably, this was also when discourse picked up on multiple websites where people were trying to claim trans men and mascs are hiding behind "being afab", and were peddling recycled transmedical/bioessentialist rhetoric that was common back in like 2014.

I've started seeing trans women marked as transphobic for standing against racism in regards towards trans men/mascs of color (notably black and indigenous MOC), transphobic behavior towards all trans men/mascs, intersexism, and exorsexism.

Shinigami Eyes isn't safe anymore. Who knows if its always been safe, even. They cherry pick who gets chosen as good and whos bad. I figured they always had peoples best interests at heart, but considering how abysmally racist, intersexist, and transphobic it is towards trans men and mascs now? I don't even know. Without transparency in why users are marked as transphobic there's no way in hell anyone should trust it. No source behind anything.

Hey! Transfem here!

THIS IS NO LONGER A TOOL FOR MARKING TRANS-SAFE SPACES.

It used to do that, but the developers have some serious issues with transmascs and intersex people, especially BIPOC queers. They deny that transmascs/trans men experience transphobia in a unique manner (transandrophobia) and silence intersex voices.

Do not get this extension. The devs also copy-paste the same cookie-cutter response and, evidentially, are transphobic themselves (presuming there is more than one)


It's worthless guttertrash now. Maybe get it if the devs clean up their act.

While I feel like this service can be helpful in certain instances, lately people have been abusing to target queer friendly people they don't agree with (often intersex folks, who's voices need to be heard in every discussion of queer liberation). It is very disappointing to see a service I formerly believed to be helpful and queer-friendly show it's true colors like this. I hope that the moderators rectify this mistake, as this service has been very helpful for me and others in the past. It is just sad to see it destroying it's own reputation by throwing vulnerable members of the queer community under the bus.