Reviews for Bookmark search plus 2
Bookmark search plus 2 by aaFn
259 reviews
Developer response
posted 5 years agoHello, if you read the add-on description page https://addons.mozilla.org/en-US/firefox/addon/bookmark-search-plus-2/, you will see it has to fetch the favicon for each bookmark to be able to display them (the little images at front of bookmarks). This is because Firefox doesn't give access to them. The add-on does that only once.
Alerts mean that you have plenty of bookmarks to malwared URLs .. :-)
You can deactivate favicon fetching in the options page, and you won't get any alert. But then all icons will be the standard "no favicon" icon. We are just waiting that Firefox gives us that access -> https://bugzilla.mozilla.org/show_bug.cgi?id=1315616
Thank you, aaFn.- Rated 5 out of 5by Firefox user 15907683, 5 years agoThis is a great add-on that I've used for a long time with no adverse issues. It's also an add-on that I really like.
However, it has developed a sudden glitch. It will throw out a brief message that is on screen for only a fraction of a second that reads as follows: "BSP2 detected a desynchronization and is reloading bookmarks from FF API. Please wait..."
This happens as soon as I type in any of the following four letters: "a", "g", "s" and "t". It will not display any results for those four letters.
All other letters and numbers work fine. Have uninstalled and reinstalled BSP2. Have restarted FF several times but no luck so far. No idea where to turn to get this resolved.
Update: developer answered quickly (thanks!) and also found the problem which will be resolved in the next update. See his reply to this message. Thank you!Developer response
posted 5 years agoHello, yes I also fell on that recentlyl, it seems the behavior of FF bookmark search API changed a bit and is now returning two special folders I was not seeing before, and which are not expected (namely the "Tags" special folder ... but also the Mobile bookmarks special folder even when it is empty).
Since they are not expected, BSP2 believes there is a de-synchronization with the FF DB of bookmarks, and attempts a reload.
This is corrected in 2.0.76 which will be out soon ... I filtered out those two items when appropriate from the search result gotten from FF API.
Thanks aaFn.
====================== Update ===================
2.0.76 is out now with the fix for extended search responses.
Should be all ok now, sorry for the inconvenience, aaFn. - Rated 5 out of 5by vtibi, 5 years agoI can't believe that firefox lacks this functionality by default.
- Rated 5 out of 5by Firefox user 15892547, 5 years agoAbsolutely BRILLIANT. Thanks so much. It returns folder folder names in search results, which the built in search doesnt :-) Even site icons eventually show up, just takes some time.
- Rated 4 out of 5by Notlaw, 5 years agoCould have an option to open into the Ctrl+Shift+B window [not shortcut].
Or just be able to move folders by dragging them into Firefox bookmark bar [under address bar].
The major thing I like in this addon is the option to search bookmark folders.Developer response
posted 5 years agoHello @Notlaw, thank you.
The first demand is made impossible by FF for Web extensions, the Boomark History window is not customizable and no add-on can run within it, sorry.
The second one you mention is in fact hitting a bug I opened on FF some time ago https://bugzilla.mozilla.org/show_bug.cgi?id=1531539
=> we are waiting for it to be corrected by FF so that it can work.
=> Meanwhile, the work around is to drag the folder you want to move to the bookmark bar, and to drop it into the "Bookmarks Toolbar" folder inside of BSP2, at top of the bookmark tree .. and the result will be the same.
Thank you, aaFn. - Rated 4 out of 5by Claudio, 5 years ago
- Rated 5 out of 5by Firefox user 15022029, 5 years agoSuggestion: focus searchbar upon opening sidebar (alt + b)
Developer response
posted 5 years agoHello, thank you.
On focus, alas this is not yet possible, Firefox does not allow that -> https://bugzilla.mozilla.org/show_bug.cgi?id=1502713
Impatiently waiting that FF fixes the bug .. :-) - Rated 3 out of 5by Jezze, 5 years ago
- Rated 5 out of 5by they86, 5 years agoI think it's insane that this is not native in Firefox. - Thanks for the fix.
Also ability to customise the font and line spacing was above and beyond my expectations. Great!
Suggestions for further improvement:
- I think the Options-page is a bit hidden away - why not make it accesable right from the star icon?
- the "advanced click" option is very useful (choose if you want to open the bookmark or show the location in your bookmark folder), but it's a bit tricky to remember that you have to click the WHITE SPACE NEXT TO the search result. - Maybe you can add some kind of icon, like an arrow or something, to make it clearer and more user friendly?
- shortcut for opening the sidebar:
* it seems to be impossible to overwrite the Firefox Bookmark shortcut?
* adding the "shift" button as an option to program your own shortcut would come in handy
- a shortcut for opening Bookmark Search "full screen" (in a tab) would also be nice.
Thanks for your great work!Developer response
posted 5 years agoHello they86, thank you. Interesting suggestions, so lets go through them one by one:
- Ok, I will add access to the options page in the right click menu of the BSP2 icon in the toolba,r for easier / faster access.
- Indeed, now that you say it, I see that the visual mouse pointer shape to distinguish an active part (favicon and text in Advanced mode), from a non active part (blank in advanced mode, or whole line on folders or whole line on bookmarks in Simple mode), is not really consistent across Simple and Advanced modes in search results.
So in 2.0.74, I am improving the behavior as follows: a pointer mouse cursor (little hand) will now only show on active parts to open bookmark (= favicon and text in Advanced mode), while a default mouse cursor will always show on non active parts to locate bookmark item (= blank in advanced mode, or whole line on folders, or whole line on bookmarks in Simple mode).
This should be visually clearer and easier.
- You are correct, an add-on cannot override the Firefox bookmark shortcut. This is Firefox security feature.
- "Shift" alone is not possible, it can only be with "Ctrl" or "Alt" .. See "Shortcut values" in https://developer.mozilla.org/en-US/docs/Mozilla/Add-ons/WebExtensions/manifest.json/commands
- Ok I will see if I can also add a shortcut to open BSP2 in a tab -> https://github.com/aaFn/Bookmark-search-plus-2/issues/130
Thanks, aaFn. - Rated 5 out of 5by Yuri, 5 years agoExactly what I was looking for! So much easier to get around in the bookmarks now. The icons look a little bit antiquated, though. Anyway, an extremely useful tool. Thanks.
- Rated 5 out of 5by blankon, 5 years agohi, nice addons and thx for your effort, its almost perfect, except...
"Bookmark search plus 2" only working on sidebar, and my sidebar already used by addons "tree style tab" with thousand tab, ineffective to switch due load time...
what do you think, to better organize and integration with most popular addons like "tree style tab",
to add embed window or organize bookmark on new tab, like addons "bookmark manager view" does.
https://addons.mozilla.org/en-US/firefox/addon/bookmarks-manager-and-viewer/
=================== Edit ===============
perfect, I just edit my rating too,
I missed that feature, because the button in the hidden place.
is there any hotkey/button to access it? (without switching my sidebar first)
*as I told to you, I can't switch my sidebar easily because there is, "tree style tab"Developer response
posted 5 years agoHello @blankon, you can already run BSP2 in a new tab. Simply click on the magnifier glass button in the search box, and click "Open BSP2 in a tab" in the menu. Hope this meets your need :-)
For integration with "Tree Style Tab" add-on, this would require the developer of that add-on to allow other add-ons to open sub-windows inside it, which is not the case today (to my knowledge). Maybe in future if he/she adds that integration feature ?
Thank you, aaFn.
=================== Edit ===============
In 2.0.73, I added the function to "Open BSP2 in a tab" on the right click menu of the BSP2 icon in the toolbar.
This allows you to keep "Tree Style Tab" in your sidebar, and to activate the feature without switching TST first.
This should answer your need, cheers aaFn. - Rated 5 out of 5by EA, 5 years ago
- Rated 5 out of 5by Firefox user 15655133, 5 years agoEs gibt keine Alternative zu diesem perfekten AddOn.
- Rated 5 out of 5by Firefox user 15610611, 5 years ago
- Rated 5 out of 5by Firefox user 12532989, 5 years agoPerfect ! Thank you..
I can now see parent directories again :) - Rated 5 out of 5by Bogo, 5 years agoI am TOTALLY happy with this addon!!!! I only use the sidebar BSP2 instead of the genuine Bookmark-sidebar.
Is it possible, that you even integrate the option, that when clicking on a folder, that another open folder collapses (closes)? It is a pain to always close a used folder, before opening another folder (otherwise the list within the sidebar gets longer and longer and longer as all opened folders stay open...)
AND: Could you integrate the possibility of expanding all folders and closing all folders?
Thank you for thinking about this. I am very grateful for all your efforts....Developer response
posted 5 years agoHello @Bogo, thank you. Interesting idea that opening a folder closes all others at same level .. I'll look at adding it as an option.
On the other one, yes this is planned, it's going to come soon now -> https://github.com/aaFn/Bookmark-search-plus-2/issues/31
aaFn
=================== Edit ===============
Version 2.0.71 is now published, with the possibility of expanding all folders and closing all folders as an Advanced submenu in the context menu. - Rated 5 out of 5by atreyu, 5 years ago
- Rated 3 out of 5by DanC, 5 years agoHave been using BMS+2 for several months as it is the closest approximation of the old, wonderful Opera bookmark search that found bookmarks IN CONTEXT as opposed to FF presenting them in isolation. In large part, BMS+2 works well except one can't add a description while in its mode.
However, I have always been flummoxed with the appearance of TWO bookmark trees one for FF and one for BMS+2. How can that be? This morning I clicked on a BM to delete it but it wouldn't delete. Then I went to FF BM tree and some BMs I saved in BMS+2 were not there. So I restarted FF and all of my BMs saved today were gone.
What kind of weird behavior is that??Developer response
posted 5 years agoHello DanC.
yes I too was missing the old Opera function which they removed. I was then using Firefox and the first version of this add-on by Alice0775, before Firefox switched to Web Extensions in FF57 and deactivated XUL for add-ons, which broke the that add-on. So I decided to give a second birth to it (hence the "2"), however there are several restrictions as documented on the add-on description page.
One is that Firefox doesn't give us access to Tags, Keywords, Descriptions .. see https://bugzilla.mozilla.org/show_bug.cgi?id=1225916
Some others are Firefox API slowness when add-on use some functions .. which forced me to implement caching techniques and other features to be able to handle properly large number of bookmarks of some users (up to 80000 bookmarks for now).
And last is that because XUL is not authorized anymore, BSP2 cannot integrate with Firefox UI, it has to provide its own UI, and so this is why you have 2 trees.
Because of that, there are opportunities for Firefox and BSP2 cache to get desynchronized.
Rare, but can happen, especially when FF doesn't terminate well. For such cases, you will find a "Reload all bookmarks from FF now" button in the options page. I advise that in your case, you press it to resync things.
If you're worried about such desynchronization events more than slowness, or if you are fortunate to not have a lot of bookmarks and then things are quick enough, you can also enable the option "Revert to old behavior of loading full bookmark tree from Firefox API at each restart". BSP2 will be slowlier at each restart, but there won't be any desynchronization.
i hope this helps, else please open an issue on https://github.com/aaFn/Bookmark-search-plus-2/issues. Thanks, aaFn. - Rated 4 out of 5by Firefox user 13400558, 5 years agoI love BSP2. But I had a mishap that I hope can be solved. I reorganized some bookmarks with BSP2. Firefox crashed during shutdown. Now BSP2 contains the right bookmark structure but Firefox doesn't. Neither "show all bookmarks" nor the FF bookmark menus contain the missing folders or the bookmarks in them - the ones I was working with.
I know the missing folders and bookmarks exist somewhere because BSP2 displays them -- even after restarting the computer. Is there a way to get them into the main Firefox bookmark set?
Stan HilliardDeveloper response
posted 5 years agoHello Stan, yes this is one of the benefits of BSP2 to go past FF corruptions in the native bookmarks DB when they appear / already exist.
A careful way to proceed, but which loses tags if you have any (until FF allows us to copy tags :-( ) is typically:
- Go in BSP2 to a folder which is not showing anymore in the native sidebar
- Copy it (right click and click "Copy")
- Go to another place which is not corrupt
- Right click there and click "Paste before" or "Paste into" if a folder
- Go to the native sidebar, and verify the copied folder is there
- When all is good (can take some time when folders are big), you can delete the old "lost" folder in BSP2
A bolder way to proceed, but which should keep the tags, is typically:
- Go in BSP2 to a folder which is not showing anymore in the native sidebar
- Cut it (right click and click "Cut") - you are safe so far, as Cut does not remove anything, it just says that a future paste will be a move instead of a copy
- Go to another place which is not corrupt
- Right click there and click "Paste before" or "Paste into" if a folder - this step is safe in fact, except when FF crashes or the corruption is too strong .. should be very rare though
- Go to the native sidebar, and verify the moved folder is there
Hope this helps. If any problem, let me know on https://github.com/aaFn/Bookmark-search-plus-2/issues
Note that FF corrupts its bookmark DB on its own .. BSP2 does not play a role in that.
This is why there is a backup function of bookmarks in FF (saved everyday automatically by FF, you can find the backups in one of the menus of the Bookmarks Library). - Rated 4 out of 5by sharon clerc, 5 years agoNot quite as simple as original parent folder finder, but at least it works.
- Rated 5 out of 5by oric1, 5 years ago
- Rated 4 out of 5by Firefox user 14179994, 5 years agoI love this app, but I wish it would also allow you to do tags and keywords like the regular firefox bookmarks do!
Developer response
posted 5 years agoHello, yes we would all love to, but no app can do that for now, this is not provided by Firefox :-(
If you can vote on Bugzilla to get this promoted, please do so .. it is P3 right now, and 4 years old -> https://bugzilla.mozilla.org/show_bug.cgi?id=1225916 - Rated 4 out of 5by wtfs, 5 years agono method to select multiple bookmark at sametime in the sidebar, such as holding ctrl or shift keys to select multiple bookmark to move or delete.
Edit: multiple selection is finally added, a must needed feature thank godDeveloper response
posted 5 years agoYes, this is a todo https://github.com/aaFn/Bookmark-search-plus-2/issues/29 .. It will come, but not sure when yet :-)
------------------------------- Edit ------------------
Hello @wtfs, now multiple bookmarks selection is possible, since version 2.0.103 :-) ! - Rated 5 out of 5by loutvi, 5 years agoaddresses effectively the need of easily identifying the containing folder of a bookmark in Firefox; a feature which is desperately missing as built-in in firefox since ever
- Rated 5 out of 5by SSG, 5 years ago